I read an interesting article in the paper a few days back regarding all the upheaval in Ukraine with Russia, and how this is affecting the relationship between Russia and the U.S. when it comes to the International Space Station (ISS). I know a little about NASA and the ISS and its operations, and I can tell you this issue is troubling to me. We have an ISS mission operations control center in Russia, as well as here in the U.S. at the Johnson Space Center in Houston, Texas. Our astronauts train in Russia for the Soyuz flights that ferry them back and forth to the ISS. The following is an excerpt from an internal NASA memo:
“Given Russia’s ongoing violation of Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, until further notice, the U.S. Government has determined that all NASA contacts with Russian Government representatives are suspended, unless the activity has been specifically excepted. This suspension includes NASA travel to Russia and visits by Russian Government representatives to NASA facilities, bilateral meetings, email, and teleconferences or videoconferences. At the present time, only operational International Space Station activities have been excepted. In addition, multilateral meetings held outside of Russia that may include Russian participation are not precluded under the present guidance.” SOURCE: NASA Watch
From what I know, there are teleconferences at least weekly and emails probably daily. Before each flight of a vehicle to the ISS, Flight Readiness Reviews and Stage Operations Readiness Reviews are typically held and ALL international parties attend in person or via teleconference. Most configuration changes of any kind often require all international partners to agree and sign-off on. I have no idea what exactly has been deemed essential and how this is impacted by the sanctions the U.S. currently has in place with our partner in space.
We are dependent on Russia to get our astronauts to the ISS. We have much invested in the way of funding and are gaining enormous benefits in areas that will not even be realized for years – the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer could possibly change the basic concepts of physics; medical studies regarding cancer, aging, medications, etc.; as well as many other important scientific and technological advances. When NASA’s Space Shuttle Program ended, with no crew vehicle to take its place, the price of the seats on the Russian Soyuz went up, now costing approximately $70 million. Sometimes two of those seats belong to us, meaning that cost doubles.
I’ve read that Charles Bolden, NASA’s administrator has said Russia’s space agency Roscosmos will continue to cooperate with NASA as far as providing our astronauts a ride to and from the space station. He has assured that Russia depends on us and can’t run the station as we supply many essential power and operating systems. He mentioned in 2008, when there were diplomatic issues involving Georgia, there were no problems. Well at that point the ISS was not completely assembled. I doubt both of the robotic arms were onboard and I’m pretty sure the satellite deployers had not been delivered. The robotic arms are used for so many tasks and operations and the small satellite deployers are a definite advantage in this newer area of technology. In my opinion, the only guarantee we have is that Russia wants our money.
My understanding is that the Russian cosmonauts spend the majority of their time living and working in the Russian modules and predominantly only work on their own science investigations – which if you ever look at a NASA Expedition Press Kit, these science experiments/investigations are written in Russian, so if you do not know the language or have an interpreter, most people have no idea what the Russians are really working on. (Though I am sure someone at NASA does.) They may even use their own communication systems separate of NASA’s, as well.
Also, if I understand correctly, the Russian Zvezda Service Module is the main piece of the station when it comes to powering all other systems and if it goes down – the whole thing can die. Having said all that, the Russians could just shut the parts of the U.S. side of the station down that they didn’t want to use and that would be that. I’d be willing to bet, there’s probably ways to disconnect the U.S. modules and let them deorbit, if so desired.
The space station was conceived as an engineering feat, to result in not only great advances in science and human space exploration, but also as a model for international cooperation – peace, compromise and teamwork. Under the circumstances though, I can’t help but wonder if Russia would try and use their advantage and take over the station.
I don’t know, and I am not an expert on any of these things. I am just thinking about the possibilities of what can happen with operations of the space station and the ramifications of the state of the world and our own affairs in this country presently. WE have a lot at stake here and I don’t think most of us really even know it. It’s not just about who owns, runs, funds the ISS and the science we get from that – it’s about who ultimately owns the skies with satellite technology and just as an aside, human space exploration.
I just realized North Korea has a space agency. North Korea has a space agency and China has landed a rover on and is exploring the moon and Russia is the only way our astronauts can travel back and forth to the space station that we as a nation and as taxpayers own a big part of. Regardless of your opinions of NASA, space exploration, and its funding . . . Is it just me or is this picture disturbing?
Just something I was thinking about . . .
20 thoughts on “Russia and Your Space Station”
I am not sure how I feel about the whole topic, but I did enjoy reading your post about it…. it got me thinking. 🙂
y.prior – thanks for reading & commenting! That’s truly my mission here . . . just to get people thinking!!! 🙂
I’ve wondered the same. But Many other countries have an interest in the ISS. Also the first private contractor, SpaceX is making a cargo flight scheduled for next week. They are making a man rated ship ready in a couple years.
distantshipsmoke2013 — I know SpaceX is working hard to get it done!! And the ISS has like 15 countries total partnering, though the station is comprised of 2 segments – the U.S. segment and the Russian segment. But until SpaceX or one of the other 3 companies working this endeavor gets a manned crew vehicle up & running – we are dependent on Russia to get the crew back and forth . . . that could get dicey under the circumstances. And lets be honest . . . if the worst happened and only Russian cosmonauts were living aboard . . . you know the old saying . . . possession is . . . just saying. Probably why this concerns me so much! Thanks for reading & commenting!
This is very disturbing to me as well. I am still pissed at our government for ending the shuttle program without first having an alternative on deck (and I don’t mean the alternative of relying on Russia, or any other country). It is a travesty and a shame we have no manned space program. We should be working diligently to get to Mars.
I know LAM . . . when I first started getting interested in all of this in the late 1990s, that was the big talk around NASA – going to Mars!! Not sure what happened after that except a lot of young engineers & others were incredibly disappointed. And thanks for reading & commenting – so glad you enjoyed the post!!
It has not been all that long ago,most of us remember,I’m sure that in elementary school we would be involved in drills where we were to hide under our desks when the whistle blew..This was to make it easier to do a body count should anyone be left to tally such gruesome numbers.Our alleged leaders have crawled into an un-holy union with our sworn enemies in an effort at bringing closure to old wounds.
I’ve never been a fan of our space program and having known a good number of folk that work for NASA have found it mostly to be workfare for engineers..
That said,it should be alarming that we have put ourselves in such a precarious position as to be at the mercy of foreign powers such as Russia.
More than a little food for thought.
Thank you ,Sadie,for the insight that you have as to the inner workings there.It was an eye opener.
Thanks for reading & commenting Clark! It is a more than a little food for thought . . . like I said regardless of what you think of NASA . . . it’s a precarious position we have placed ourselves in (the U.S. & NASA, I mean)! Glad you enjoyed the post 🙂
Not something that I’ve ever considered before but I can tell you after reading this I’m sure as hell giving it some thought. That bit about the kits etc being in Russian and the US being dependant on them to reach the space stations plus the little list at the end of the post about who else is now doing the star trek thing – well let’s just say under my bed is starting to look pretty inviting and I’m pondering the concept of an underground house – just a thought. As for Australia – we can’t keep track of a plane, let alone go into space ALTHOUGH it would be an excellent place to send a delegation including our Prime Minister and then just forget to pick them up!! Hmm food for thought that one. Ok so I’m off to panic about the eyes in the sky – you have a nice day!!.
Just saw this comment Jenni – so sorry I haven’t responded sooner! Now there are new developments on the Russia and ISS front. Definitely something to be thinking about in the overall scheme of things. No need to panic about the eyes in the sky though – they have been there for quite some time 🙂
🙂 Good to know.
Utterly disturbing. Definitely something to think about and the government should reconsider. Yikes!
Just saw this comment sweetlittlenetwork – so sorry I haven’t responded sooner! Exactly why I have been paying attention to it – not exactly sure what to make of it. Thanks so much for reading and commenting!!
That’s quite okay. Thank you for taking a moment to reply. And you’re welcome
Imagine they Russians hold hostage the Americans in the Space station because of the ongoing problems in Ukraine…that would be something. That would be a Tom Clancy novel.
I think, as well as many other astronauts(I watch way too many documentaries) that the U.S has completely relayed it´s power in space not only to the Russians but the Chinese too. The U.S or NASA has lost the backing of the American people and the government.
Just saw this comment charlypriest – so sorry I haven’t responded sooner! I was thinking the same thing about the novel LOL 😉 I totally agree on your other comment, too – NASA has lost the backing of the American people, which is sad as they really do so much more than we realize – though I will be the first to say there is some waste, too. Thanks so much for reading & commenting!
My pleasure Sadie.